Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
Source: Review Copy from Author
Following her tender and sweet Pride and Prejudice inspired contemporary romance, Pride, Prejudice and the Perfect Match, Marilyn Brant gifts us readers with the sequel we were eagerly hoping for! (We wanted us some more Bing-a-Ling!) After seeing Beth Bennet and Will Darcy come together through a most unlikely medium, readers can now see what happens between the two closest people in their lives – Jane Henderson and Bingley McNamara. While it isn’t imperative to read Pride, Prejudice, and the Perfect Match first before reading Pride, Prejudice and the Perfect Bet, you may want to so you can see how Beth and Will fall in love and meet Jane and Bingley before they meet each other.
Both books in this series are entertaining and endearing reads, and while they do pay tribute to Jane Austen’s characters and novels, they don’t follow the personalities and events too closely. Beth and Will meet through an online dating site, Bingley is a ladies’ man with a proclivity for wagers, and Jane’s outward appearance of sweetness and serenity may just be a mask. Pride, Prejudice and the Perfect Match focused on Beth and Will and their tangled web of lies, Pride, Prejudice and the Perfect Bet centers on Bingley and Jane and their intense feelings towards each other – whether they be of dislike, irritation, confusion, attraction, or affection.
One thing I’ve always enjoyed about anything I’ve read by Marilyn Brant is her complex, well-drawn, and engaging characters. I greatly enjoyed spending more time with Bingley and Jane, and discovering all their hidden layers. I loved exploring each character’s past, learning their insecurities and relationship needs, and witnessing them overcome all their hang-ups. At times though, I felt Jane still seemed a little unsettled and unable to find her own identity. She was “lost in the crowd” of her big family, taken for granted, used by her ex-boyfriend, and tired of being packaged into a “box of warmth, kindness, and sweetness.”
“But she wasn’t sure she even knew who she was anymore. Or if she could trust herself if she did. Or if she’d ever feel comfortable sharing the deepest secrets of her soul with any man again.” – page 138
I loved this moment of clarity and soul-searching Jane had partway through the novel, but I kind of felt we never saw the answers to all her questions. I wanted to see more of the real Jane.
Another aspect I love about Marilyn Brant’s novels is that they are always so much fun! Whether we are touring Europe with her grandmother S&M club (ahem!…Sudoko and Mahjongg) or celebrating different holidays at a charming small-town inn, Marilyn always includes an abundance of details, descriptions and delicacies that add such a richness to her story! I greatly enjoyed seeing the “dates” Bingley and Jane had together, especially the meal he made her! And I thought the movie night where they watched Casablanca and When Harry Met Sally were superb choices. Loved the parallels – “men and women can’t be friends” and when they both called Will and Beth at the same time! LOL! (I see what you did there, Marilyn!) In addition, I also loved the sweet scenes with Charlie (Beth’s son) and how he thought of Jane and Bingley as his friends. 😉 Awww!
Of the two books in the Perfect series, Pride, Prejudice and the Perfect Bet is my favorite. Bingley was just too adorable…(I know, big surprise…I have a thing for Bingleys I guess!) Loved his sweet boyishness, easy-going charm, his latent protective and serious side, and his decisive, take-charge behavior. Reminded me of someone I know… 😉
Nice review Meredith 🙂 I thought this book was such a fun read, and I agree with you, I really liked The Perfect Match but I liked The Perfect Bet even more.
🙂 🙂
Thanks, Ceri!!
And it looks like Meredith shares our love of that “When Harry Met Sally” scene!
Thank you, Ceri! Marilyn writes such fantastic stories, doesn’t she?!? I wish there could be another installment in this series! Maybe with Jane’s brother? 😉
Definitely one of the best rom-coms evah!
Meredith,
Thank you *so* much for your delightful review of Bingley & Jane’s story. I loved reading your thoughts! That picture you chose from “When Harry Met Sally” is just perfect, btw 🙂 . As I’m sure you guessed, that film is one of my longtime favorites, and the phone call scene — along with the Baby Fish Mouth one — are two moments from the movie that never fail to make me laugh!! And being that you have a particular love of Mr. Bingley (*grin*), I’m especially thrilled that you enjoyed my hero!
Thank you for writing this lovely sequel, Marilyn!!! Your fans greatly appreciate it! 😉 I was smiling during the whole chapter, loved seeing them discuss the movies. 🙂 Definitely laugh out loud scenes. Oh yes, TingleyBingley did not disappoint at all!
Great review Meredith. I’ve read both books and loved them, but would say the ‘Perfect Match’ is my favourite of the two…lol!
Carole, thank you so much for reading both stories!! And I’m glad you liked Will & Beth’s romance best. Each couple should have their champions 😀 .
Very true! My opinion may be a little bit biased given that my husband reminds me more of Mr. Bingley than Mr. Darcy. 🙂
I need to get on the stick and read both of them. I have the first book so I have no excuses. Glad Bingley and Jane’s story was a good one.
Ohhh, thanks, Sophia Rose! I’ve got my fingers crossed that you’ll enjoy them both!! 😉
I think you’ll love them Sophia Rose! It’s great how one great story is now two! 🙂
I thoroughly enjoyed both books and can’t really decide which one I like best! Thank you Marilyn, for writing them. Thank you Meredith for a great review, as always.
Anji,
*Smooch!!*
And thank YOU for taking the time to read them!
Avid readers are my heroes ;).
xoxo
So glad to hear that Anji! I hope Marilyn will continue to write more! 🙂
Again, my comment is very late. Both books are in my amazon shopping cart now. I always try to read the JAFF’s that my fellow Janeites recommend, plus it’s great to read an interview. Thanks, Meredith.
Marilyn, all my best wishes with your writing, and I’m anxious to read your books!
My pleasure, Catherine! Hope you enjoy this series!