Dear Nameless Stranger – Jeannie Peneaux

What If the Bennet Sisters Had an Anonymous Guardian?

Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

Source: Austenesque Jolabokaflod!

TYPE OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation

THE PREMISE: Soon after Elizabeth returns from Hunsford, tragic events occur that leave the five Bennet sisters orphaned and soon-to-be homeless (thanks for your decency and charity, Mr. Collins!). But then an unexpected and anonymous guardian sends them an offer of an available cottage of their very own plus a chaperon, and only asks for monthly letters from them in return…

WHAT I LOVED:

The Premise: A startling change in circumstances, a story full of letters, a Regency homage to Daddy Long Legs – there is so much I love about Dear Nameless Stranger! Ms. Peneaux delivers such a heartwarming and genuine tale about kindness, compassion, and altruistic intentions. And our beloved cast of characters – especially the five Bennet sisters and Mr. Darcy are so lovingly and endearingly portrayed.

Merry-Making: Even though there is grief and sad trials, it was lovely to see the Bennet sisters enjoy some simple pleasures and discover joy together in new ways. I loved the picnics, the gardening attempts, the furniture investigations, and the exquisitely touching Christmas scene. These lovely vignettes together felt somewhat reminiscent of Louisa May Alcott, and I loved the feelings of pure innocence and good cheer they evoked.

Unique Voices: Through both their own letters and the retelling of events from various perspectives the Bennet sisters are each given a distinct voice. I loved all that we learned about each Bennet sister through their writings. The bulk of the letters readers see are Elizabeth’s, and they are brilliantly impudent and charming – she does not fail to make everyone fall in love with her. In addition, Kitty’s letters are a delightful surprise with her distracted ponderings and discerning observations. And through the other sisters’ various accounts, their personalities and perceptions are satisfyingly revealed.

Mr Darcy: Love him, love everything he does, love every single one of his responses. In the second half of this story readers see the same events that took place in the first half, but from Mr. Darcy’s POV. And I loved the revelation of his thoughts and emotions behind his actions. His intentions are supremely magnanimous, his eagerness – completely adorable, and his thoughtfulness – incredibly moving.

Growing Attachments: Through their strife and startling life changes, the Bennet sisters grow closer together. No more selfishness or peevish squabbling, instead there is staunch support and devotion. It was lovely to witness the harmonious bonds grow and the loyalty flourish between these sisters. Equally enjoyable was witnessing Mr. Darcy’s growing attachment and affection for each of the Bennet sisters – not just Elizabeth. He learns to appreciate each of them for their unique attributes and develops a brotherly love for them that matches his love for Georgiana.

WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:

Nothing! It is perfect.

CONCLUSION:

Dear Nameless Stranger is an exquisitely charming and absorbing story full of honesty, hope, and heart. I adored Jeannie Peneaux’s skillful execution of this premise, and her thoughtful portrayal of these characters! I’m so glad I finally got to read this one!

Add to Cart I Add to Shelf

21 comments

This one also earned a 5 star review from me. Great review, Meredith.

Oh thank you Meredith! I love this review and this book is definitely going on my list! Every point you make seems to point to an ideal story! Keep up the great work and take care 🙂

Loved this the first time I read it — thanks for the reminder to queue up for a reread!

This was a wonderful book! Daddy Long Legs is a favorite of mine, so I liked the homage!

Ooo! I was hoping you would like this one when I saw it on your Aug. agenda. I loved it when I read it on the forums and have it in my TBR to read again. Beautiful review.

Thanks Meredith. Hope the rest of August treats you well. <3

I’m glad to see a review of this wonderful book. I absolutely loved it and added it to my “Favorites” collection. Everything about it worked, especially Elizabeth’s voice. She was perfect.

I have been eyeing this book for a long time. You have convinced me that I must have it. Thank you!

This is on my TBR list and your review makes me even more eager to read it.

Gerrit Kestermann says:

August 12, 2021 at 4:07 pm

One of my favourits. Have listened to the audiobook countless times!

Reply

I hadn’t heard of this one. Love the Daddy Long Legs style story.

Wonderful review, Meredith! I too absolutely loved it!! I would love to see a sequel as to where all the sisters receive their HEA! I think it is time for a re-read of this one! I love this author’s novels!

Thanks for this lovely review. I was not aware of this book and will check it out.

Yes, yes… and hello… yes! I loved this book and agree with your review on every point. Heavy sigh.

What an interesting twist in the plot.

denise

You make me want to read this book!

Time to give this one a go , cause it sounds like an amazing read 😀

I absolutely loved this book! Great review!

This story is perfect! It is the book I reread often. It is thought provoking and always prompts me to be an actual letter writer and share with another. Reading the sisters’ perspectives is interesting, as it always is within a family. Simply a lovely story, I love it.

WOW Meredith, your review has made me want to have this book right now! LOL
It really seems a beautiful story and I saw, too, the reference to “Daddy Long Legs”. Besides, the cover is so charming with the lavender and the feather!
What a good novel you got for Jolabokaflod!
Thanks for your captivating review 😉