Prevailed Upon to Marry – Mary Smythe

What If Mr. Darcy Pilfered Mr. Collins’s Bride?

Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

Source: Gift from Publisher

TYPE  OF NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation

THE PREMISE: Mr. Bennet receives a concerning report from Mr. Jones, and so he entreats his favorite daughter to reconsider the repugnant marriage proposal she just refused (because Mr. Collins obstinately will have no other). But just when she is about to walk down the aisle, someone quite unexpected arrives and gives Elizabeth a second option…

WHAT I LOVED:

  • Distressing Reality: Being a woman in this time means not always having the freedom or right to choose your life. A reality that was previously unknown to Elizabeth. But not anymore. She has no choice, no time, and no alternatives. It is a rather bleak looking future for our Lizzy. I appreciated how Mary Smythe portrayed Elizabeth’s coming to terms with her fate and the spectrum of emotions she experienced.
  • A Devil May Care Darcy: Ooh! I loved this swift-acting and overcoming-any-obstacles kind of Darcy. He is determined and he is tenacious. I absolutely adored him. I loved the moment he arrived in such panic and turmoil fearing he might be too late. His precipitate and persevering actions displayed the depth and strength of his regard more than any ill-chosen words could.
  • Confined Communications: The road is long and bumpy for our travelers and they have a copious amount of time to think and talk. I always love these types of situations  – when the hard questions come out and there is no escape from challenging discussions. I loved witnessing these characters learn to understand each other better and grow closer together through these scenes. These tense circumstances and their extreme isolation allowed their relationship and feelings to evolve at a more accelerated rate.
  • Thoughtful Understanding: Elizabeth is blindsided by the turns her life takes several times in this novel. Twice she has agreed to marry a man with whom she never fathomed as her choice. But she adapts marvelously. I appreciated how Elizabeth considered both hers and Mr. Darcy’s situation, and that she recognized his potential regret. She was very rational and was not one to willfully misunderstand or quickly judge.
  • Growing Intimacy: It doesn’t take Elizabeth long to become aware of the many estimable qualities of the man she is about to marry. And as a result she warms to his company and his person. *swoon* I loved how this relationship developed. Their progress and actions felt natural and plausible with just the right timing and the right circumstances. (NOTE: some scenes – nothing explicit – are suited for mature audiences).

WHAT COULD HAVE BEEN BETTER:

  • I thought it all was excellent as is

FINAL THOUGHTS: 

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿  It’s not everyday you see Mr. Darcy steal a bride and make for Scotland – what an exciting romp!

💗  A beautiful love that grows with understanding, esteem, and earnest devotion.

🙈  Mr. Collins gets what he deserves in the most satisfying of ways!

 

Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

14 comments

  1. This is a great story! I love this impulsive, romantic Darcy. I love how Elizabeth, with Jane’s encouragement, throws her lot in with Darcy. I love how they spend the carriage ride talking to each other so they are both happy with their marriage. This is on my reread list and I think it must be soon.

  2. Loved this book! ODC on an adventure. Thanks for the review Meredith, I agree with your thoughts. Mr. Collins added all kinds of humor to this, and he does get his ” just desserts’ lol. I plan to add this paperback to my library. Cheers

  3. I read this book as soon as it came out. It was absolutely wonderful. Your review is just perfect and makes me want to read it all over again!

  4. Thanks Meredith for this great review! I also want to see the “steal a bride” issue and the journey to Scotland 😉

  5. I’m so glad you liked this one. It was a great story. Now I want to reread it! I know, I’m a broken record. But hey, if it’s a great story it’s worth rereading.

Leave a Reply

Your conversation and participation are always welcome; please feel free to "have your share."