Oct 292018

What Happens When Edmund Marries Mary Crawford and Fanny Builds Her Own Life?

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Source: Review Copy from Author

TYPE OF AUSTENESQUE NOVEL: Sequel to a Mansfield Park variation, A Contrary Wind

TIME FRAME: Begins a year and a half after the close of A Contrary Wind, Fanny is 20.

SERIES: Book 2 of 3? Potential readers should read A Contrary Wind first to fully appreciate and understand all that is taking place in this second book of the series.


Following her inventive and thoughtful Mansfield Park variation which explored what happens if Fanny Price, tired of being told she was an ungrateful burden to the Bertram family, decided to take control of her own future, Lona Manning continues to follow the members of the Bertram, Price, and Crawford families, who are on decidedly divergent paths from their courses in Jane Austen’s Mansfield Park. In this sequel readers will observe how Fanny is making a new life for herself outside London and see more of her friends Mrs. Butters and writer, William Gibson, follow Lieutenant William Price in his naval missions to Africa, and witness the estranged relationship between Edmund and Mary.


  • Captured Their Voices: One thing that continues to impress me most about Lona Manning’s writing is her deft and developed depictions of Jane Austen’s characters. It is not every author that I say this about but I feel Lona Manning is quite skilled in capturing the voice and matching the tone and style of Jane Austen’s characters. I especially thought this with the letters exchanged between Mary and Edmund in this story. Mary’s cleverness and subtle conniving and Edmund’s rigidity and strong moral compass are expertly portrayed.
  • Fanny and Edmund: It is no small feat to take characters that many Jane Austen fans dislike and find ways to represent their characters that garner more admiration and inspire esteem. Even though Fanny is painfully shy and has sometimes wants to run and hide, readers will applaud the moments when Fanny gathers her courage and bravely holds her head up high. And while we all know Edmund has some weakness and blindness when it comes to Mary Crawford, in this series we see what happens after his eyes are opened and how he struggles with his feelings of betrayal and disillusionment as he determines what is the right course for him to take. It was interesting to see new sides and slight alterations to these characters and yet know that in fundamentals they have not changed.
  • Secondary Characters: I am thoroughly enjoying the secondary characters – those created by Jane Austen and those created by Lona Manning – we meet and see more of in this tale. I’ve always loved William Price and I am so glad he is featured a lot in this series – especially since his story-line has some romance in it! In addition, Mrs. Butters is a true champion of Fanny and I love her strength, compassion, and open candor. And lastly, I found a lot to admire in William Gibson. Although I was not so sure about him at first, I love how he saw, understood, and appreciated so much about Fanny, (minus a few misunderstandings!) Other characters such as John Price, the Blodgetts, the Delingpoles, and the Bellinghams were all interesting inclusions that added richly to this story’s cast.
  • Historical Tie-Ins and Extras: Included in the back matter of this book is a wealth of helpful information for readers – a list of Dramatis Personae, an afterward, background information, and discussion questions for Mansfield Park, A Contrary Wind, and A Marriage of Attachment. I enjoyed perusing all these extra materials, and it was lovely to learn more about the author’s creation of this story. And I was impressed to learn how many of the characters and events used in this story were real people and events! What clever and plausible ways Ms. Lona found to include them in her story!


  • Balance and Pacing: Just a minor quibble, there were some moments of higher activity and development that I would have liked more page time for – especially when it came to our couples. I also felt some of the events of the conclusion were a little fast-paced.


Well-crafted, meticulously composed, and richly researched – A Marriage of Attachment is another remarkable and praiseworthy story by this skilled author! This series is definitely a perfect choice for readers who love stories that plausibly flesh out Jane Austen’s characters and are not afraid to implement some surprising new twists.

Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

Follow My Reviews!

No spam guarantee.

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )

  17 Responses to “A Marriage of Attachment – Lona Manning”


    Wonderful review! I loved this book and ‘Contrary Wind’! I am definitely looking forward to the next one by Lona. As you said, ” It is not every author that I say this about but I feel Lona Manning is quite skilled in capturing the voice and matching the tone and style of Jane Austen’s characters.” I totally agree!


    I have not read this book but would wait until the series in complete as I find I have difficulty remembering details from the first books when there is a space of time until the second, or third, is published.


    I skimmed because I still need to read book one. Glad you loved it. 🙂


    I am so happy to see books about Fanny and Edmund…I think there is so much that can be explored. I am going to be adding both books to my list!


    Meredith, thank you for this lovely review! I love William Price, too. He is such a sweetheart. I think he’s about to called out to serve in America, in the War of 1812, in volume 3. But I’ll take good care of him.


      Oooh! I like that better than him continuing to go to Africa! 🙂 Thank you so much for this lovely series and for the opportunity to read both books! I am so glad you are writing stories about these characters!


    I adored A Contrary Wind and can’t wait to read A Marriage of Attachment! I am likely in the minority in loving Mansfield Park in the first place and in admiring Fanny Price as much as (if not more than) Austen’s more popular heroines. (And definitely MUCH more than Emma whom I despise!)

    I thought that the first book did such an amazing job of extending Fanny’s character while keeping her consistent with Austen’s depiction. I am soooo looking forward to this second book and just splurged and bought a copy! 😀

    Susanne 🙂


      Ooh good for you!!! I think you will love A Marriage of Attachment! I am so glad to hear you love Mansfield Park. I am rereading it at the end of this year.

      So true what you said about A Contrary Wind, all the characters were developed in plausible ways.


    Great review Meredith. I just realized that I didn’t have this on my bookshelf. What happened??? Oh well. I added it after reading your review. Thanks and say hello to Mr. Bingley.


    Terrific review. I think Lona Manning has a real gift for making the writing feel authentic to the era and reimagining a story!


      Yes…authentic, detailed, but at the same time not too heavy with history and things the reader wouldn’t find interesting. She definitely does have a gift!


    I didn’t realise that this was 2 of 3. Great review , Meredith!

Your conversation and participation are always welcome; please feel free to "have your share."