Jun 142010

An Anti-Austen Addict Finds Jane Austen

Rating: 3 out of 5 stars

Source: Giveaway Win

Georgina Jackson, feeling a mixture of apprehension and dread, makes her way down to her literary agent’s office, wondering what it is her agent wants to see her for. It probably has nothing to do with her first novel from two years ago, which received raved reviews from critics but was not a big seller, and most likely isn’t about her second book, in which Georgina is unable to write beyond the first chapter. What could her churlish agent want with her?

Georgina soon learns the reason she has been summoned: she has received a commission to complete a recently discovered fragment of novel for a famous author. While this sounds like a fantastic professional opportunity and an answer to Georgina’s financial problems, she cannot accept this assignment. Why? Because the famous author she is suppose to imitate and complete the fragment for is none other than Jane Austen!

The novels of Jane Austen and Georgina Jackson are as different as night and day. Georgina writes dark and tragic novels, filled with misfortunes and misery, and Jane Austen writes (in Georgina’s opinion) “about young women falling in love and getting husbands.” Or at least that’s what she believes she writes, since Georgina has yet to read a Jane Austen novel. Gasp!

Georgina has been given an insurmountable task. Not only does she need to write a believable pastiche of a Jane Austen novel, but she needs to do it in three months time! It would be a substantial challenge for any writer to complete a one hundred and twenty thousand word novel in twelve weeks time. Let alone a writer who needs to spend time reading and researching an author she knows nothing about. Assisting Georgina in this project is her scientist landlord, Henry, his fourteen year old sister, Maud, and their Polish housekeeper, Anna, who all adore Jane Austen and are very knowledgeable on all things Austen. Furthermore, these characters also help Georgina escape her loathsome agent and publisher who are relentlessly harassing and nearly stalking her.

With such a fantastic premise and intriguing plot, I found myself very excited to read Writing Jane Austen. While I enjoyed many parts of this story such as the minor characters, the references to Jane Austen novels and characters, and the jabs at the Austen industry, there were some aspects of this novel I did not enjoy. The first being our heroine, Georgina Jackson. I understand the author wanting to portray Georgina as very anti-Austen and create conflict with her difficulties writing a Jane Austen novel, but I feel she maybe carried it too far. Georgina spent so much time avoiding her work, running from her agent, and procrastinating that I started to find her a little unlikable and immature. Perhaps if Georgina showed some significant maturation or responsibility, readers would feel a little more sympathetic and endeared towards her.

Another aspect of this novel I wasn’t too fond of was how some characters and plots seemed a little superfluous and often disregarded later on in the novel. For example, one time when Georgina is hiding from her publisher, she stays at her ex-boyfriends apartment. The author gives a brief background on this ex-boyfriend and his relationship with Georgina but never alludes to his existence again. Another scenario is when Georgina visits a friend in Bath. There is a couple of chapters devoted to this trip, yet it seems a little isolated and does not connect to the main plot very cohesively.

With six lovely Pride and Prejudice sequels already published, Ms. Aston is becoming a well-known and admired Austenesque author. I am delighted that Ms. Aston decided to deviate from Pride and Prejudice sequels and write an Austen-Inspired/Jane Austen Chick-Lit novel. Whatever the genre is, Ms. Aston’s novels always illustrate her great love and veneration for Jane Austen and her world. I dearly hope Elizabeth Aston continues to pen more Austenesque novels!

Follow My Reviews!

No spam guarantee.

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )

  8 Responses to “Writing Jane Austen – Elizabeth Aston”


    I read Aston’s “Mr Darcy’s Daughters”, so I am actually familiar with the author. Finally, haha. Anyway, this seems to be such an inviting read. Great idea, definitely. Also, great review. Thanks for sharing!


    Hi Irena! I love Mr. Darcy’s Daughters! I thought it was a terrific book! I look forward to hearing your thoughts on this one if you do read it!


    I’ve got a great problem, Meredith! I always want to give a book a try after reading your reviews! But I can’t. I’d need to live twice at least to do ALL the things I ‘d like to do. This Georgina here makes me think of some girls of my acquaintance who think JA just writes about balls, girls falling for boys and finding a husband in the end. Unbearable to my devote ears. How does Georgina change her mind? Does she actually change her attitude?


    LOL! Maria. I know what you mean, there are so many books and such little time!

    Without giving too much away I will say that Georgina eventually buckles down and reads all od Jane Austen’s novels, and from that her opinion of Jane Austen greatly changes!


    I was going to say how much I was looking forward to your review of this book, and how sorry I am that it was a bit disappointing, but after reading your response to Maria’s comment I have to add my two sense. She tries to do this WITHOUT reading Austen!?!? What a nincompoop! More than anything else, such arrogance in a heroine deprives me of all desire to read this book. I’m sorry, as I liked Aston’s other novels, but I think this one is firmly on the back burner.


    “What a nincompoop!” HAHA! Alexa, I wouldn’t say she “tried” to write without reading Jane Austen, she just avoided the whole project all together. Her attitude was a little frustrating at times. I didn’t like how it took her so long to realize how much was at stake for her in this project.


    I had mixed feeling about this one too Meredith, though I think I liked it more than you. It was a very interesting concept and the heroine’s transformation was slow but rewarding by the end. It just took a lot of anxiety and procrastination for her to get there. It also lacked romance, which might have upped my approval a bit more. Anyway, thanks for the review. I am always amazed at how you can read and review so many books. You leave me in the dust. LA


    I agree with you, Laurel Ann, about the romance part. I liked the little romance that was in this novel, I just wished it wasn’t so brief and developed a little more!

    Me leave you in the dust? Hardly! I cannot imagine doing something as huge as a Pride and Prejudice group read with all the organization and insight you provide! You have a true talent for blogging, Laurel Ann!

Your conversation and participation are always welcome; please feel free to "have your share."