Mar 152017

Hi readers, I’m excited to share another of my Austenesque Top Ten lists with you today!

For those who haven’t seen this kind of post before, it is where I share some of my all-time favorite Austenesque works.  Sometimes I group them by novel (Persuasion, Sense and Sensibility),  sometimes I group them by sub-genre (Sequels, Modern-day Adaptations), and sometimes I group them by theme (Summer, Halloween). 😉

A year ago I decided I best tackle the most popular novel and sub-genre out there in all of Austenesque…Pride and Prejudice Variations

It is way too hard to pick just 10 favorite Pride and Prejudice variations though, I’ve read hundreds!  So I broke it down a little by years. A year ago I shared my favorite 10 Pride and Prejudice variations from the years 2007-2011. And today I am sharing my favorite Pride and Prejudice variations from 2012-2014.


* These lists are based only on the novels I have read and reviewed on this blog and are my top ten favorites.

**These lists are subject to change.  


(in alphabetical order)

A Fair Prospect Trilogy (Volumes I-III)

Author: Cassandra Grafton

Type of Novel: Variation

My Rating: 5 out of 5 stars (for all three!)

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

*yes…I’m sneaking in 3 for 1!

“If you are an ardent admirer of Pride and Prejudice variations, then you need to do yourself a favor and devour this expressive and eloquent trilogy, if you haven’t already! Filled with soul-searching, slow-paced exhilaration, and sweeping romance, Cassandra Grafton’s A Fair Prospect is definitely one of my favorites!”


Dearest Friends

Author: Pamela Lynne

Type of Novel: VariationMature Audiences

My Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

“Dearest Friends is an “excessively diverting” and enthralling Pride and Prejudice variation! I recommend this story to readers who love sensual romances and don’t mind seeing some of Jane Austen’s characters slightly altered. I can hardly wait to read more thoughtful and inventive tales by Pamela Lynne!”


Haunting Mr. Darcy

Author: KaraLynne Mackrory

Type of Novel: VariationParanormal

My Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

“I’m so very eager to see what KaraLynne Mackrory comes up with next, her enchanting and sensitive Pride and Prejudice variations belong in every Janeite’s library! Written with keen observations, sharp wit, and deep emotions – Haunting Mr. Darcy is the kind of story that enthralls the reader and keeps them captive until the very end (and haunts them all the while in between!)”


Mr. Darcy’s Noble Connection

Author: Abigail Reynolds

Type of Novel: Variation

My Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

“Fiercely loyal and protective of his friends and loved ones, honorable and noble even in the most difficult of predicaments, principled and respectful – Elizabeth Bennet can hardly find reason to accuse Mr. Darcy of being ungentlemanly in this novel! I just loved seeing him act so heroically and honorably! So many excellent traits to admire and love!”


Pirates and Prejudice

Author: Kara Louise

Type of Novel: Variation

My Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

“Looking for an epic and grand adventure? With Pirates and Prejudice, Kara Louise delivers a sweeping tale that is thrilling, bold, and beautifully crafted! Brava, Kara! Thank you for bringing Darcy and Elizabeth into the world of pirates, buried treasure, bandanas, and billowy white shirts!”


The Falmouth Connection

Author: Joana Starnes

Type of Novel: Variation

My Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

“Brooding, fervent, persevering, frustrated, protective, and brave – Ms. Starnes’s depiction of Darcy in this novel is everything that is admirable and worthy, proving that Mr. Darcy is indeed the penultimate romantic hero!”


The Journey

Author: Jan Hahn

Type of Novel: Variation

My Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

“Oh my, what a riveting and heart-pounding adventure! With a magnetizing and dangerous bad boy, a couple who believes their love for each other is unrequited, a damaged reputation, and the threat of scandal this novel had me consumed!”


The Madness of Mr. Darcy

Author: Alexa Adams

Type of Novel: Variation

My Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

“Alexa Adams created a compelling and unique journey for our dear couple to traverse and I truly loved every minute of it! The ending was pure satisfaction in every sense of the word – all past sorrows were erased and I felt each character experienced healing and peace. I highly recommend this exquisitely crafted variation!”


The Subsequent Proposal

Author: Joana Starnes

Type of Novel: Variation

My Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

“Achingly romantic and exquisitely expressive – The Subsequent Proposal is a beautifully blended story with our favorite, albeit mismatched, couples.”


When They Fall in Love

Author: Mary Lydon Simonsen

Type of Novel: Variation

My Rating: 5 out of 5 stars

My Review   I   Add to Cart   I   Add to Shelf

“An informative and vivid tour of Florence, an inventive and intriguing premise, a gratifying character development for Jane Bingley, and a poignant and emotional romance – what more could you ask for?!?”


Have you read any of my favorite Pride and Prejudice variations from 2012-2014?

Are any of them your favorites?


Disclaimer: The Amazon links used in this post are affiliate links.




Follow My Reviews!

No spam guarantee.

Leave a Reply

50 Comments on "Favorite Pride and Prejudice Variations (2012-2014) – Austenesque Top Ten List"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest
J. W. Garrett

Oh, I love your list. I’ve read most of them… there are three that I have not gotten to yet. Time… so little time. Thank you for sharing your list.

Brenda Webb Bigbee

What a great list! I have read so many great books that I tend to forget some as the years go by, but most of these I have read and loved! Great list and a gentle reminder of those I missed. Thank you.


Oh… I have read them all and you have mentioned several of my favourites : A Fair Prospect, Haunting Mr Darcy and When they Fall in Love. The others variations I have also loved reading.

Your blog is certainly a source of inspiration and information.

Thank you for sharing with us.

Abigail Bok

I can see I have my work (or my pleasure) cut out for me! I’ve read only one–Haunting Mr. Darcy, which I found charming. Thanks for the pointers!


wonderful list


Some of my all time favs on this list, Meredith, including The Madness of Mr Darcy (which I only discovered last year!!), Mr Darcy’s Noble Connections and The Journey.

Thank you so much for including me in it too! You’ve made my day, my week and quite possibly my year! <3

Pamela Lynne

Wow!! What an unexpected joy this is! Thank you so much, Meredith. I am both honored and humbled to be listed with these JAFF legends whom I have followed from the beginning of my Austenesque adventure. Wow. Thank you!

J \"Joy\" Dawn King

Great list. You have some of my all-time favorites on there. The cave scene in Jan Hahn’s book (swoon!). The swinging from the yardarm in Kara Louise’s book (swooning again!), and the garden AND cove in Joana Starnes’ Falmouth Connection (double swoon). The moors in Abigail Reynolds’ book (downright faint) and Sebastian (what more needs said, Pamela Lynne Alexis). I’m surprised how many of the others I have not read. A few have been so long ago I need to reread (especially Cass Grafton’s trilogy). Thanks for the list, Meredith. As always, excellent.

Jennifer Redlarczyk

How could you ever stop at 10? All of these are great and I could easily add 10 more. Thanks for your sharing. Jen Red


Hi Meredith,
I haven´t read any of them but I remember well when you spoke so good of Joana Starnes´s books as well as Cassandra Grafton´s. They all seem so exciting!. And I would like to have time to read Mary Lydon Simonsen´s story because of Florence as the setting of the novel (sigh!) and, of course, “Pirates and Prejudice” because it must be such a fun and romantic reading with swashbuckling scenes LOL!.
Thanks for this list, Meredith, it´s really helpful 😉


I have read and enjoyed 6 of these, Cass Grafton’s trilogy, both of Joana’s, Abigail’s, Pamela’s and KaraLynne’s. All wonderful! And I have three others on my wish list but even though I have a number of books by Mary, I don’t remember this one so will definitely be checking it out. Thanks for another great list Meredith

Pam Hunter

Great list! I have them all, but I admit that I’ve not read them all yet. There just aren’t enough hours in the day!

Sheila L. Majczan

I have read all of these…great selections! I truly thank you and admire you for all the hard work you put into giving up these lists. In reading over 175 or even 200 per year there is no way I could select 10 out of those I read. But good for you.

Jan Hahn

Thank you, Meredith! Lovely to have The Journey included among such good books.

Mary Simonsen

Hi Meredith. So glad you enjoyed When They Fall in Love. I appreciate the shout-out.


I did better on this list than last year’s, 8/10 this time! Just “The Journey” and “When They Fall in Love” left to tick off. They’re all such wonderful books with so many memorable scenes in them. I love the way you’ve snuck all three of Cassandra’s trilogy in, Meredith. Quite right too!

Sophia Rose

Fun to read your lists. I’ve read four of those and have three more on my TBR pile so I’m sitting pretty to enjoy some good ones it looks like.

Rita Deodato

I love your lists Meredith! From these I’ve read 9 and 8 of them would also be on my too 10 :))
It’s a great selection!


Thanks for the list.

Joana Starnes

I loved these books! HUGE thanks, Meredith, for your ever so kind words about mine, I can’t tell you how happy I am that you liked them!!

Thank YOU for your wonderful friendship, for all the encouragement you gave me over the years, from my first steps into JAFF, and for making Austenesque Reviews the amazing blog that it is! Hope it gives you as much happiness as you give us, every day!

Alexa Adams

Oh Meredith! I am so excited to see The Madness of Mr. Darcy here, and in such excellent company! You are undoubtedly the queen of lists. Brava and thanks for the love.


All are wonderful variations. I loved them all so much that I can’t choose which one enchanted me the most. After reading each one of them 2 or 3 times via kindle unlimited, I decided to purchase them ALL to read and enjoy daily. Congratulations to all of you, my dear and favorite authors. You guys make my day to day life so much more enjoyable. Joanna, your Unthinkable Triangle opened the door to the wonderful world of Jane Austen Fan Fiction for me. Though not listed here, it will always be one of my most favorite.


Meredith,what a great list!!!
Have read all except two,and loved all those that I read.
One of my absolute favourites is KaraLynn Mackrory’s A Spifitual Courtship-Haunting Mr Darcy.
I remember,when I started reading it, that I just knew it would be something really fantastic! Thankfully I was right!!

Michelle H
Oh drat, I commented (long winded as usual) and clicked something and poof, it disappeared. If this shows up twice I’m going to be so embarrassed. Now that I have that possibility hanging over my head, I’ll be much briefer. I know I’m extremely behind in reading your blog entries, crazy busy here with getting ready to move soon. I especially looked forward to reading this one on a quieter day, though. I just don’t know how you kept it to a list of ten! Nut! Not you, the idea. 😉 I have all but still have three yet to… Read more »
Michelle H

And yes, that was more brief.

%d bloggers like this: